Public concern for concussions has grown in recent years, as has the field of sports medicine. Between 2010 and 2016, there were approximately 283,000 annual emergency department visits among children for sports-related traumatic brain injuries. About 45% of those visits were associated with contact sports.
Baseline tests measure normal cognitive function and physical abilities, and they play an important role in concussion treatment and recovery, especially for sports-related concussions. Having an individual’s baseline measurement allows healthcare professionals to compare back to it in the event of a head injury.
Digital cognitive assessments are particularly useful for capturing baseline data and assessing the effects of a concussion as soon as it happens. This article will describe the benefits of baseline testing and how cognitive testing can be used to establish baseline cognitive performance data.
Article Highlights
Baseline concussion testing captures an athlete's healthy cognitive function before the season begins, giving clinicians a personalized benchmark to track recovery against if a head injury occurs.
A baseline concussion test is a test that measures cognitive and physical functions—like coordination and balance—when an individual is not impaired or injured. Sports, especially contact sports, carry a high risk of concussion. Concussion baseline tests are mainly used for athletes, typically before the sports season starts.
Baseline testing is essential to detecting differences when screening a patient for a concussion immediately after an injury. It’s relatively quick to retest an athlete to see if their scores are meaningfully different from baseline in the case of a possible concussion.
Baseline testing is also an important part of a concussion treatment plan. Patients can perform the same assessments as they did for their baseline throughout treatment and recovery. These results can then be consistently compared back to their baseline results, in order to see if their results are approaching baseline or are still differing significantly from their expected level of healthy brain function.
Baseline testing is important because it provides more—and more accurate—data for understanding changes to a patient’s cognitive performance post-injury and offers a personalized benchmark to measure recovery against. With baseline test results, a patient can immediately be screened for a concussion after a head injury. Baseline tests are also an accurate way to track recovery compared to an individual standard and to determine when a patient is approaching their pre-injury levels of function.
The CDC estimates that between 1.6 and 3.8 million concussions occur annually in the U.S. However, these numbers might underestimate the prevalence, as many people with concussions do not know or seek medical attention.
While concussions in sports are a major concern, concussions can come from a number of places. Any hit to the head or sudden jolt can lead to a traumatic brain injury or concussion, regardless of whether the individual loses consciousness or not. Motor vehicle accidents, workplace injuries, and falls are all common causes of concussion.
Consistent baseline testing can also help get athletes used to the importance of cognitive health care and reduce stigma around concussion diagnosis and treatment.
There are many benefits to using baseline testing throughout the concussion diagnosis, treatment, and recovery process. UCLA Health defines three major benefits of using baseline concussion testing: early detection of concussions, objective assessment, and benefits to return-to-play decision making.
Patients may have a hard time determining whether they’re experiencing concussion symptoms immediately after an impact. However, if they can immediately perform the same test as their baseline and their performance has declined significantly, a concussion can be confirmed quickly.
It’s important for patients to get diagnosed and start a treatment plan as soon as possible so as not to exacerbate symptoms and lengthen recovery time. An early treatment plan supports symptom and pain management for patients. The sooner a patient knows they have a concussion and can take steps towards recovery, the better. High levels of either cognitive or physical exertion after a concussion have been shown to worsen symptoms and lengthen concussion recovery time.
While interviews and questionnaires are important for understanding a patient’s experience of their symptoms, objective tests are also important for concussion treatment. Objective assessments offer cognitive performance data to create a complete picture of the patient’s brain health alongside their self-reported symptoms. These tests are easy to do repeatedly and easy to compare back to, especially when available digitally.
Dr. Williams, medical director of the Kerlan-Jobe Center for Sports Neurology, explains that a “brain injury is not always visible,” which can lead to difficulties for patients.
Having an objective test that’s able to measure how far patients are from their function at baseline and whether it’s improving is invaluable for treatment and the delivery of patient-centered care. Dr. Williams found that by using the computerized cognitive tests through Creyos, he was able to “demonstrate where impairment and improvement were happening.”
Returning to regular activities too early can be dangerous and lead to a risk of further injury. If a patient is injured again before the last concussion has healed, this can lead to worse symptoms that last longer.
Baseline concussion tests can assist medical professionals in making return-to-play decisions. It can be difficult for a concussion patient to accurately recall if symptoms have changed since before the injury. Patients may also minimize or underreport their symptoms, wanting to return to play, work, or other activities quicker.
Baseline testing and sideline testing work in tandem to support concussion screening and diagnosis, but while baseline testing is done before an injury, sideline testing is a post-injury assessment done immediately after a head injury.
Sideline assessment can lead to a decision of whether or not to pull the athlete from play. If there is a suspected concussion, the athlete should not return to play or physical activity until they’ve been thoroughly assessed by a healthcare professional. While exercise can be good for the brain, the risk of reinjury or overexertion can negatively affect the cognitive health of a concussed individual.
Sometimes, trained professionals are available on the sidelines to assess athletes after any injury. But this isn’t always the case. The responsibility of sideline assessment can often fall to untrained coaches or sports officials. As such, standard automated tests that can easily and quickly compare symptoms to baseline information are incredibly helpful. This way it’s much easier to manage concussions and to determine whether an individual differs significantly from their usual function.
Both baseline testing and sideline testing contribute to concussion diagnosis and recovery. They work together, with a baseline assessment being compared to a sideline assessment.
Concussion testing can also be used to monitor recovery progress after an incident. Post-injury assessments can be compared to baseline test results (or sideline test results where a baseline isn’t available). Ongoing testing can be used to track concussion recovery from the time of an incident through return-to-activity. This monitoring can be done through platforms like Creyos, where initial baseline results are easily compared to current tests to track improvement longitudinally.
First, a patient can complete a baseline assessment before any concussion occurs. On the Creyos platform, this means administering the cognitive tasks along with a self-report questionnaire such as the Rivermead Post-Concussion Symptoms Questionnaire (RPQ) to establish a baseline for both cognitive performance and symptoms.
Next, a post-injury assessment is completed at the time of clinical presentation. Re-administering the same cognitive tasks and the RPQ in Creyos measures acute cognitive change and captures the severity of any symptoms the patient is experiencing.
Then, providers can use Creyos for serial monitoring. Repeat testing at regular intervals during recovery tracks domain-specific change over time and helps guide decisions about return to activity. When retesting, individual tasks can be administered on their own or as a full set.
When performing a baseline concussion assessment, a variety of tests can be helpful, since patients will all be affected by concussions in different ways. For example, one patient may struggle with memory but have no issues with balance, while another patient may have an opposite set of symptoms. Patients can be assessed in as many areas as possible to facilitate whole person care.
Once a baseline has been established pre-concussion, healthcare professionals will need testing tools post-concussion to further track and measure symptoms and recovery. There are a number of concussion assessment tools available to support this. In this section, we’ll outline some common concussion assessment tools and their different uses throughout concussion care.
Cognitive tests can assess neurocognitive functions that are known to be affected by concussions, such as short-term memory, concentration, and reasoning. This is an important part of concussion testing, as cognitive symptoms can have an effect for a prolonged period of time, even longer than other symptoms. They can also continue showing effects in the brain under imaging scans, even when athletes have otherwise been cleared to return to play.
To gather baseline scores and for those scores to be usable, sports neurologists and concussion specialists need to be equipped with the right tools. Computerized cognitive tests are one way to help concussion specialists gather the required information.
Computerized cognitive tests can shorten the time it takes to access testing and make retesting highly accessible. Many computerized cognitive tests can be done in the clinic or at the patient’s home without any need for specialized referrals, meaning that healthcare professionals can retain patients in their care and establish continuity of care.
In addition, digital cognitive tests and more in-depth neuropsychological testing can offer a detailed look at various cognitive domains that may be affected by a mild traumatic brain injury, such as memory, concentration, and reasoning.
Creyos measures cognitive function through the administration of scientifically validated cognitive tasks. Each of these tasks measures a distinct cognitive function that can be affected by concussion. Creyos then automatically generates reports that can be easily interpreted by a provider to measure and track recovery across specific domains like attention, working memory, and executive function.
The following Creyos tasks are recommended for evaluating cognitive function in individuals with suspected concussion or head injury:
Digital cognitive tests from Creyos can help make the overall baseline testing process more convenient for patients and healthcare practitioners alike. The Kerlan-Jobe Center for Sports Neurology found an increase in patient retention and 10% fewer referrals when switching to Creyos computerized cognitive tests. Patients can complete assessments in the clinic, on the same day, or from their home. This can help make for a more accessible patient experience.
Baseline testing is particularly important for athletes and has many benefits for concussion assessment and treatment. It can help with clearer interpretation of post-injury testing and provides a more objective assessment, and supports return-to-play decisions. We also discussed how to perform a baseline test and the types of concussion assessment tools that are available.
Baseline concussion testing is invaluable when it comes to supporting patients with sports-related concussions. Cognitive assessments are an essential part of concussion baseline testing and can lead to a more complete treatment plan and understanding of patient health.
Reviewed by Mike Battista, Director of Science & Research at Creyos
Mike Battista specializes in brain health, cognition, and neuropsychological testing. He received his PhD in personality and measurement psychology at Western University in 2010 and has been doing fun and useful stuff in the intersection between science and technology ever since.